The Pursuit of Holiday Perfection (and Other Bad Ideas)
We spend weeks planning the perfect family holiday, only to remember why we don't invite these people over more often.
Every year, millions of us willingly subject ourselves to an exhausting, expensive, and self-imposed undertaking known as hosting the family Thanksgiving dinner.
We shop, we clean, we cook, and we organize the big day around relatives who every year manage to stroll in late, complain about something, start a political argument, or find a way to make the whole occasion about themselves.
When it's all over, we collapse into bed, swear we're never doing it like that again, and start planning how to do it better for Christmas.
I think it's genetic. I grew up watching my mother and grandmother do it, and I learned nothing.
I remember Thanksgiving as a kid at my Grandma's house.
Like most holidays, there was lots of family, great food, everyone laughing and talking, kids running around, someone getting hugged, someone getting scolded for roughhousing, someone sneaking food from the kitchen (usually me).
Those Thanksgivings have become a bit of a blur for me over the years, but I remember the experience of them, as well as certain moments that became tradition whether they were intentional or not.
Like Grandma working overtime to make sure everything was perfect.
On Thanksgiving, there would be fifteen or so of us crammed into her 1,300-square- foot home. The house was built in the ‘60s and had been the model home, dubbed the “honeymoon cottage”, which, I’m guessing, was meant as a starter home, not meant for our motley bunch that showed up for dinner every holiday.
We’d gather around the dining room table, which was flanked with additional folding tables, each adorned with white vinyl tablecloths and my grandparents' treasured ceramic decorations.
Dinner was served on rectangular Styrofoam cafeteria trays with those little compartments for everything, because the honeymoon cottage didn’t come with a dishwasher. The sink was just big enough to wash one pot at a time, much less a bazillion dishes from our T-day feast.
When my grandparents finally installed a dishwasher, it was a half-size model because that’s all the kitchen space they could give up.
And yet, every time they fed us until we were stuffed to misery.
Turkey with giblet gravy, dressing, sweet potatoes topped with not-quite-burnt marshmallows, green beans, can-shaped cranberry sauce, and her famous Alabama biscuits.
Those biscuits were practically currency in our family. Grandma had to make dozens of them to stop the arguing and hurt feelings when someone would eat (or greedily sneak bagfuls home) the very last one.
Those biscuits are now MY tradition, and having to deal with the pain-in-the-ass of making them as an adult…well, I know now that her making dozens of them to keep the peace was an act of LOVE for us.
Before dinner, we’d loiter in her kitchen (and in her way), starving and hypnotized by the delicious aromas, trying to sneak a bite before dinner; she was the one who told us to show up hungry, after all.
At the table, our food would sit cooling and untouched while we did the interminable “so what are you thankful for this year” conversation around the table.
I was thankful for the people with the fastest responses. My Apple Jacks were long gone, and my stomach was beginning to contribute to our conversation.
Looking back, I fully understand now just how much work went into all that. All that prep: shopping, cooking, cleaning, decorating, and everything else needed to pull off Thanksgiving for a crowd the size of a rugby team.
And every year, someone would inevitably say, “You didn’t have to go to all this trouble", which we meant, but she’d wave it off; she wanted us to have the best Thanksgiving she could give us.
And I get that now, because I can still easily get caught up in putting in an insane amount of effort for things nobody even asked for.
Neither Grandma nor my mother needed to go to such lengths to make the holidays special for us. We appreciated every bit of it, but the memories I have aren't just from how nice it all looked.
All I cared about back then was enjoying the holiday with my family.
And Alabama biscuits.
On top of everything else, Grandma took on the role of family peacemaker. She hated conflict, and did whatever it took to snuff it out when she could.
No small feat, considering the delightful assortment of personalities in our family: loud, smartassed, opinionated, quirky, or just clinically incapable of attending a family gathering without creating drama.
You have relatives who show up chronically late every year, shambling in the door with weak excuses until you start lying about the start time just to get their ass in the door.
Or the relatives who like to make little comments about the food, or someone’s weight, or what’s on their plate, followed by the inevitable, “I didn’t mean it like that.”
In our family, that was the Barracuda.